The roll of ministers who served the church during its 275 years of existence is as follows:
| 1715-1815 | |
| Joseph Smith | 1715-1736 |
| Edward Eels | 1738-1776 |
| Gershom Buckley | 1778-1808 |
| Joshua L. Williams | 1809-1832 |
| 1815-1915 | |
| Joshua L. Williams | 1809-1832 |
| Zebulon Crocker | 1833-1847 |
| George A. Bryan | 1849-1857 |
| James A. Clark | 1859-1863 |
| William K. Hall | 1864-1865 |
| Horatio O. Ladd | 1865-1867 |
| Thomas M. Miles | 1868-1870 |
| A.C. Hurd | 1871-1873 |
| Myron S. Dudley | 1874-1884 |
| Henry G. Marshall | 1885-1904 |
| Frederic M. Hollister | 1904-1909 |
| Homer W. Hildreth | 1909-1919 |
| 1915-Present | |
| Homer W. Hildreth | 1909-1919 |
| Harvey Carmichael | 1919-1929 |
| Eugene M. Bushong | 1929-1933 |
| James Meek Hamilton | 1933-1937 |
| Charles Sumner Osgood | 1937-1946 |
| Edwin Raymond Carter | 1946-1964 |
| H. Victor Allison | 1964-1969 |
| Gordon Grant Avery | 1969-1973 |
| Printice M. Toler | 1974-1980 |
| William J. Clark, Jr. | 1980-1986 |
| Douglas G.J. Van Veldhuisen | 1986-Present |